Heat pump vs gas boiler — the numbers, and every grant that changes them

HeatPumpSwitch › By house type › a 2003-2011 semi-detached house

Heat pump vs gas boiler: a 2003-2011 semi-detached house

A worked example with this building's own numbers, not an average. Everything below is calculated from the assumptions listed with it, and you can change any of them in the calculator.

Gas boiler now
£1,042
Heat pump
£856
Difference per year
£186
Simple payback
29.6 yrs
Gas boiler now
£1,042
Heat pump
£856

Assumptions behind these figures

  • House: semi-detached house, 2003-2011, 95 m²
  • Space-heat demand as found 75 kWh/m²/yr
  • SCOP 3.6 @ 40 °C
  • Assumed existing boiler efficiency 90 %
  • Ofgem energy price cap, 1 July – 30 September 2026 (direct debit, average). Oil/LPG/coal are editable estimates, not primary-sourced.
  • Capital cost £13,000
  • Simple payback: no discount rate, no fuel-price inflation, no maintenance difference. Figures are calculations, not quotes.

Fabric and demand

Treated floor area95 m²
Space-heat demand as found75 kWh/m²/yr
Annual space heating7,125 kWh
Hot water1,800 kWh
Total delivered heat8,925 kWh
Implied heat loss4.0 kW
Assumed design flow temperature40 °C
Assumed SCOP3.6
Assumed existing boiler efficiency90 %

How these numbers were produced

  1. Delivered heat needed: 7,125 kWh (space) + 1,800 kWh (hot water) = 8,925 kWh
  2. Fuel energy at 90 % seasonal efficiency: 8,925 ÷ 0.90 = 9,917 kWh
  3. Current annual cost: 9,917 kWh × £0.0733 + £315 standing charges = £1,042
  4. Heat pump electricity: 8,925 kWh ÷ SCOP 3.6 = 2,479 kWh
  5. Heat pump annual cost: 2,479 kWh × £0.2611 + £209 standing charge = £856
  6. Running-cost difference: £1,042 − £856 = £186

Investment and payback

Installed cost, typical air source£13,000
Grant−£7,500
Net capital cost£5,500
Annual running-cost saving£186
Simple payback29.6 years

Boiler Upgrade Scheme, £7,500 (air source)

What actually decides it in this house

At 40 °C the SCOP is about 3.6, which is break-even against gas at the current cap and a clear win against anything else. This is the fabric level where a heat pump stops being an argument.

Advertising

Get quotes for your property

Compare at least three installers. Ask each one for the heat-loss calculation and the design flow temperature in writing — that number decides your running cost more than the brand on the box.

Ad. If you request a quote through this link we may be paid a commission by the installer. It does not change your price, and we do not rank companies by how much they pay.

Similar houses

All 30 house types · Calculator · Grants · Methodology